SYTYCD CROWNS TWO 'STARS'

With So You Think You Can Dance contestants already whittled down to the Top Ten, dancers pulled out all stops as they whirled, twirled, dipped and soared on the popular show this week. Despite this being perhaps the most talented crop of young dancers ever, the Mary Murphy Meter dial nearly blew off the top of the meter for one couple – Jeanine Mason, 19, of Pinecrest, Florida and her new partner, Jason Glover, 21, from Fresno California.

Mason and Glover performed a Travis Wall choreographed contemporary dance to “If It Kills Me.” Mason, prior to the dance, described it as an interpretation of best friends in a situation where the girl wants to be more than best friends, but realizes that they are not ready for that yet.

Neither the audience nor viewers were kept waiting to learn the judges’ assessment of the dance because as quickly as it ended, all three judges were on their feet giving the pair a hearty, passionate standing ovation! This third dance of the evening was clearly a best-of-the-season and perhaps even best-ever performance -- and by the show's end it had easily outdistanced the other performances in judges' praise.

Judge Nigel Lythgoe was almost giddy over the choreography, and then added that the performance was "fabulous, only made better by the people who danced it.” Lythgoe complimented, "Jeanine, that was beautiful. Jason, that was fabulous. Both of you have become stars tonight!"

Next it was Mary Murphy’s turn, but there was only silence as the usually loquacious judge was speechless. Lythgoe, generally the recipient of the full volume of Murphy’s shrill screams, took full advantage of that silence by joking, “Mary is lost for words. Do this same routine every week!”

But Murphy quickly found her voice and volume and shrieked, “You two are stars! Yes, you are. I am so proud of you. I just loved it. Jason, you've a puppy dog face, but don't let anyone under-estimate your power. And Jeanine, you have not missed a step. You keep shining brighter and brighter. You are a star!”

The names of dancers in second place, based on the Mary Murphy Scream Meter, seems almost too close to call, but in the end the edge must be given to Melissa Sandvig, 29, and Brandon Bryant, 19, who grooved to Aquarius from the musical Hair, choreographed by Tyce DiOrio.

The pair’s performance was a trip down memory lane – back to the hippie counter-culture 1960’s when young girl’s wore rings of daisies in their hair and the hand signal for Peace was the sign of the times.

The judges, obviously with fond recollections of the era, joked a bit and then turned to the business at hand.

Lythgoe marveled at the authenticity of the routine – and remarked, “Melissa, I loved the way your ballet was used, and Brandon, I loved that you used your gymnastics.”

Murphy honored the pair with one of her famous screams – and said that the performance “was unbelievable. It was groovy.”

Several “sock it to me” remarks were exchanged by the judges, proof that they indeed did recall the era -- and then it was back to business again.

Missing second place on the Scream Machine Meter by the slimmest of margins were Janette Manrara, 25, and Ade Obayomi, 20, who performed to “Love Sex Magic" with Tabitha and Napoleon Dumo as choreographers. Lythgoe told the couple, “You’ve got funk.” And Murphy screamed, “That was funky. It sure was a lot of fun.”

Raising some doubts as to this exact placement of this couple on the Scream Machine ratings, Murphy termed Janette “a spicy hot tamale." This was not a ticket on the imaginary Hot Tamale Train, but definately a strong kudo for Manrara.

Ranking fourth on the Mary Murphy Meter was the first pair to dance, Kayla Radomski, 18, and Evan Kasprzak, 21. Their Viennese waltz to "Kiss From A Rose", choreographed by Tony Meredith and Melanie Lapatin, raised a bit of concern pre-dance because of the lifts -- Radomski being the tallest girl in the competition and Kasprzak being the shortest boy. But, while the judges' comments could have been stronger, the routine was fine -- and one wonders if the dance and comments suffered because of couples' difference in size.

Lythgoe, said that the pair looked "fabulous -- the lifts and everything working so beautifully." And he added, "Kayla, I love your lines."

But Murphy came down harder on the pair, saying that at this stage of the game it was about "power, pleasure and pain." She told Kasprzak that she watched his turns with "no movement and power." And she said, "This was not good enough." But toward the end of her comments she offered some praise, saying, "Evan, when you lifted her, it was as if you were six feet tall. You have a class about you." And she told Radomski, "You never disappoint anyone."

Suffering the severest responses from the judges were the final couple of the evening, Randi Evans, 23, and Kupono Aweau, 23, who danced a Tony Meredith and Melanie Lapatin choreographed paso doble.

Lythgoe remarked that the choreography was strong and passionate, but that he was "not sure that the dancing was as good as the choreography." He told Cupono, "You lost me." And he told Randi that he thought that her wig was a mistake because "some of the chemistry was lost. It just didn't work as a couple."

Murphy was not much kinder with her assessment, "I didn't believe the wig, the dancing or the chemistry." She said that it was all about "going for it" -- and opined that moving on in the competition was going to take a level called "extraordinary."

Third judge Debbie Allen, who had given complimentary ratings to all other couples, concurred, "It is hard not to agree. You needed more time, but we don't have more time."

From this point on in the competition, it is completely up to the fans to decide which boy and girl will receive the lowest number of votes and will head home. The judges will only offer their analysis, but it is up to fans to decide which dancers they like best.

There were new pairings this week -- some that worked well, and others that found dancers struggling to become comfortable with each other.

The first number of the show was actually a Nakul Dev Mahajan choreographed Bollywood number in which all of the girls excelled. It was hailed by all three judges, Lythgoe calling it "incredible" -- Murphy saying that she could see any of the five girls in the final -- and Allen proclaiming, "You are the best five ladies we have ever had!"



And the show ended with the five boys performing a Jeffrey Page choreographed African dance. The dancing was exceptional, but there was a comical element too -- Evan, clearly the palest of the dancers, appeared a bit out of place. But he pulled this off beautifully. Following the routine, Lythgoe laughed to Kasprzak, "Evan, you looked like a dancing milkshake." It was clear that Lythgoe meant a vanilla milkshake. Murphy applauded the dancers and remarked, "Evan, how cute. This clearly is not your genre, but you held your own."

Each of the competitors performed solo routines, but none of the routines separated any of the dancers from the crowd. Perhaps the only solo that might have been meaningful was Kasprzak's -- which seemed to erase any criticism from his couples performance. He clearly looked like a new Gene Kelly!